Your Gut Knows First: Intuition in Business, and the Legacy of Rev. Janet Nohavec

Nancy Nohavec, evidential medium and former Wall Street gold trader, on the Soul Sync podcast with Jason Paul

From Wall Street Gold Trader to Medium: Faith, Trust and My Sister Janet

Soul Sync with Jason Paul, in conversation with Nancy Nohavec. Listen below, or read on for the full write-up and transcript.

"It's the voices"

In the late 1980s, a group of people walked into the office of the chief gold trader at Shearson Lehman Brothers in New York. The firm was just starting to explore artificial intelligence, and they wanted to know something simple: how did this trader make money every single day?

The trader was Nancy Nohavec. She had no college degree and had started out as a clerk on the exchange floor. Her desk sat in a room full of men with Ivy League degrees and MBAs. She took large positions in gold for the firm and dealt with central banks and governments. By her own account, she made money every day.

She was senior enough by then to tell them the truth. "It's the voices," she said. "I hear voices." Two of them got up and walked out.

When Nancy told me that story on Soul Sync, I laughed. Then I sat with it for days. I have spent most of my working life in rooms where nobody would dream of saying that out loud. In the police I called it gut feel. In recruitment I called it reading people. I never once called it intuition, let alone anything spiritual. But looking back, it was the single biggest reason anything I built worked. And when I stopped listening to it, it was the reason things fell apart.

This piece is about that quiet sense of knowing, and why I believe it is one of the most underrated tools in business. It is also about Nancy's sister, Rev. Janet Nohavec, the former nun who became one of the most respected evidential mediums of her generation. Nancy came on the podcast to honour her, and I want to do the same here.

What the research actually says about gut instinct

Intuition is not just a spiritual idea. Psychologists and neuroscientists have studied it for decades, and the findings are more interesting than either side of the argument usually admits.

The body often knows first. In a well-known 1997 study published in Science, Antoine Bechara, Antonio Damasio and colleagues gave people a card game with hidden "good" and "bad" decks. Players started choosing the better decks before they could explain why. Their skin also showed small stress responses when they reached for a risky deck, before they consciously knew it was risky. The researchers concluded that non-conscious signals guide our behaviour before conscious knowledge catches up (Bechara et al., 1997). That is a scientific description of what most of us simply call a gut feeling.

Experts read patterns they cannot always put into words. The psychologist Gary Klein spent years studying people who make high-stakes decisions under pressure, such as fire commanders and military leaders. He found that they rarely weigh up options one by one. They recognise the situation and act. Daniel Kahneman, the Nobel prize-winning sceptic of intuition, eventually worked with Klein to find where they agreed. Their 2009 paper concluded that expert intuition can be trusted when two things are true: the situation has patterns that can be learned, and the person has had enough practice, with honest feedback, to learn them (Kahneman and Klein, 2009). Asked about this by McKinsey, Klein said many business intuitions are telling you something useful, and you want to take advantage of them (McKinsey Quarterly).

Leaders use it more than they admit. Surveys of senior managers in banking, technology and utilities have found that intuitive processes are used often in organisational decision-making (Khatri and Ng, 2000). A study of 172 executives across the US, Canada, Italy and Poland found that experienced leaders lean on judgements that were once analytical but have become intuitive with practice (Chief Executive).

Where I stand

I believe in that inner knowing completely. Looking back over my life, I can see two kinds of decisions. Some were made from fear: stuck in my head, overthinking, trying to control the outcome. Others came from a strong, genuine feeling that seemed to pull me in a particular direction. When I have followed that feeling, it has never let me down. The fear-driven decisions are behind almost every mistake I have made.

I saw the same thing again and again in business. Clever, capable people would think their way out of what they felt, and get it wrong.

There have been times in my career when I did things that made no logical sense to the people around me. My advisers questioned them. Other managers couldn't see the reasoning. All I had was a feeling. Sometimes a feeling defies every bit of logic you can put against it, and it is still the right one. Following it served me very, very well.

It has happened in my spiritual life too. More than once recently, I have felt a very strong pull from the spirit world towards a decision that, on paper, didn't add up. With hindsight, I can see clearly that each of those decisions was the right one.

As a medium, I believe this goes far beyond pattern recognition. I believe your soul knows what it needs to be doing. It knows its plan. When you sit with a feeling and truly listen to it, you are tuning in to something bigger than your own experience, and for me that includes the spirit world.

That doesn't mean ignoring the facts. Even the researchers who champion intuition say it works best when it is grounded in real knowledge, and the more cautious voices remind us that a feeling of certainty can come from a story we have told ourselves (Miller and Ireland, 2005; Maia and McClelland, 2004). Fear can disguise itself as a gut feeling. So do your homework. Then get still, and learn the difference between the anxious chatter of the mind and the calm, steady pull of your intuition. In my experience, that pull is the one to follow.

Intuitives in the boardroom

It may surprise you how many business leaders already work with intuitives. They just don't talk about it. In 2015, Fortune profiled several intuitive advisers working with senior executives. One, Colette Baron-Reid, said her clients included top executives in real estate, energy and entertainment. A Toronto estate agent with around $100 million in annual sales called her "my secret weapon". Another, Laura Day, said she had worked with at least four Fortune 500 companies, and a former Seagate Technology software director told Newsweek that anyone who could afford her would get "100 times their money's worth" (Fortune, 2015). Day has since described working one-to-one with a company's chief executive, answering specific questions about people and decisions (Mic).

In my experience, the best of this work isn't about predicting share prices. It is about helping leaders quieten the noise so they can hear their own inner guidance clearly.

I want to be straight with you about the evidence. Most of it comes from the advisers and their clients. Clients are rarely named, nobody has independently tested the predictions, and Fortune noted a strong stigma around it, as well as frauds in the field. Janet herself warned people to steer clear of anyone who keeps you coming back for money. So choose carefully. But the fact that hard-headed business people keep seeking out this kind of guidance tells you something. The quiet inner voice has always had a place at the top table. It just hasn't always been given a seat.

My own story: from the police station to the boardroom

Before I was a medium, I was a police officer. I never called it psychic. I called it gut feel. I would leave the station on a shift and, more often than not, run straight into someone committing a crime. It became a running joke at the station. Nobody could explain it, least of all me. I just went where something told me to go.

When I left the police, I went into sales and then legal recruitment. I spent around ten years building my own recruitment business into a multi-million-pound company. As I said to Nancy, she sold gold and I sold lawyers. Both are complex commodities. The difference is that when your gold is sold, it stays sold. A lawyer can change their mind and walk out of the other door.

That is why gut instinct mattered so much. On paper, a candidate could look perfect. A client could say all the right things. But I learned to feel when someone was telling me the truth, when a deal was about to wobble, and when the person in front of me was the right fit, before any of it showed up in the numbers. People used to say everything I touched turned to gold. It used to annoy me, because it wasn't luck. It was hard work, and following a feeling I couldn't always explain.

When I stopped listening

There is another side to this story, and it is the part I think leaders most need to hear.

At one point my business grew so quickly it felt like I had let a monster out of a cage. The more successful it became, the more I moved into my head. I got stressed. I started overthinking, checking, controlling. I stopped trusting the quiet sense that had got me there, and started trying to force outcomes instead. As quickly as the success had come, the wheels began to fall off.

I have been at both ends of that spectrum. I have made decisions in a heartbeat that turned out to be right, and I have sat at the top of a company feeling miserable, with every spreadsheet in front of me and no peace at all. When I eventually stepped away from the business, I realised the thing I had been chasing all along was not money or growth. It was peace. And peace, for me, has always lived in the same place as intuition: in being still enough to listen.

Nancy Nohavec: the gold trader who went inward

Nancy's path to Wall Street started with everything falling apart. When she and Janet were at school, their father's business went bankrupt. Nancy describes men arriving with guns and police cars, and the family scattering. She went to live with her best friend's family, and on her sixteenth birthday they gave her a Bible inscribed with Proverbs 3:5–6: "Trust in God with all of your heart and do not lean on your own understanding." She still has it.

She had no money and, as she puts it, no family to fall back on. So she trusted. In 1979 she started as a clerk on the New York Cotton Exchange. She moved to Shearson Loeb Rhoades as a trading assistant in 1980, and rose to Corporate First Vice President and Chief Trader of precious metals at Shearson Lehman Brothers. She was one of very few senior women running a trading desk in the 1980s (Nancy Nohavec).

A woman at the top of a man's game

It is hard to overstate what that meant in the 1980s. Nancy was turned down for interviews, and she is clear that being a woman on Wall Street made it harder. The rule on the trading floor was brutally simple: if you make money, they keep you; if you don't, they get rid of you. So she made money. Every day.

She was the chief gold trader at a time when no other women were doing that job, and people knew her name around the world. She dealt directly with central banks, governments and mining companies, taking positions where a small swing in the price could mean $600,000 or a million dollars by the end of the day. She told me at least four or five people would happily have taken her seat. There was, in her words, "a lot of animus" towards the woman without a degree who kept outperforming them.

Her intuition is what gave her the edge. She describes herself as a contrarian. When central banks tried to push the market against her firm, she could feel when they were bluffing. After a while, the people who had been telling her what to do started copying her instead, desperate to know what she was thinking. She was named First Vice President, the equivalent of a managing director. When she had her first daughter in 1989, the firm gave her a large pay rise to come back. When she returned again after having twins, they gave her another and began grooming her to run one of the biggest positions on the foreign exchange desk. Instead, she followed her heart home to her girls, and went on to start one of the first hedge funds set up by a woman.

None of it came from ignoring the facts. It came from knowing the facts so well that she could hear what sat underneath them.

What struck me most was not that she used her intuition. It was how she protected it. On a trading floor, everyone has an opinion. People would come to her desk insisting she had to be long or short. Nancy learned to stop telling people what she thought. As soon as she said a position out loud, it became a fact she had to defend, and she lost the freedom to change her mind as the market moved. So she went inward. She did all the research, read three newspapers a day and knew what every central bank was doing. Then she closed out the noise and listened.

She later carried the same instinct into the art world. She talked her way into a job at Israel Sack, the famous New York dealer in American antiques, by pitching fine and decorative arts as an alternative investment. She spent five years helping steer the firm through serious financial difficulty, and resigned a week before 9/11.

For decades, almost nobody knew what Nancy could really do. Her world was bankers, lawyers and politicians, and she asked Janet to keep her name out of her books. Our conversation was the first time she had used her own surname in an interview. Her advice for anyone in business is the same advice she gives about mediumship: "Trust your instincts. Pray and meditate and go inward. Cut off the outer world."

As a medium, she brings that discipline into every reading. If what spirit shows her doesn't land with the person in front of her, she doesn't doubt the information. She looks again at how she is translating it. That is exactly how good leaders treat a strong instinct: trust the signal, and question your interpretation of it.

Honouring Rev. Janet Nohavec

Nancy came on Soul Sync for one reason above all: to honour her sister. So I want to tell you about Janet properly.

Janet Nohavec was born in Belleville, New Jersey, and grew up in Franklin Lakes, one of five children (obituary). She had memories of spirit communication from the age of four, and she and Nancy saw their first spirit on the same day, when Janet was six and Nancy four (Chicago IANDS). Their mother, a Polish Catholic who had survived the Nazi work camps, was frightened by it. So the little girl learned to hide what she could see.

Around the age of 25, Janet heard a voice in her room tell her she was going to become a Catholic nun. She joined the Sisters of Charity at Convent Station and stayed for five years. When she mentioned talking to her late grandmother, she was told that was a bad thing. She left before taking her final vows, and soon afterwards met a medium who introduced her to Spiritualism (Daily Voice).

In 1996 she founded The Journey Within, a Spiritualists' National Union church in Pompton Lakes, New Jersey. It started with ten people and grew to around 200, drawing people from New Jersey, New York and Connecticut. It is described as the first church in the United States to be affiliated with the UK-based Spiritualists' National Union (PamPam). She became an approved overseas tutor at the Arthur Findlay College in Stansted, built a client base across more than 20 countries (Omega Institute), and had her evidential mediumship researched by several university groups (Chicago IANDS). She wrote two books: Through the Darkness, her autobiography, and Where Two Worlds Meet, her guide to developing mediumship.

What I admire most is the integrity she brought to the work. Janet was outspoken about fraud in mediumship. She warned people to avoid anyone who insists you keep coming back, or offers to lift a curse for money (Religion News Service, 2004). She said other faiths ask you to believe in an afterlife, while Spiritualism tries to prove it. For grieving people, she called a genuine connection "a phone call from heaven".

Nancy remembers her as a true empath who loved everybody. In her classes Janet never singled anyone out. If she felt a student wasn't a medium but was strongly intuitive, or might be suited to tarot, she would gently guide them towards their real strength. At a family Easter dinner, Nancy asked her to say grace. Janet began, "Father, Mother, God," and the eye-rolls went round the table. Then she asked, "How do you know God's a guy?"

Janet passed to spirit on 27 July 2022, aged 65 (obituary). Shortly before her surgery, she had urged Nancy once more to go public with her own mediumship. Nancy promised she would. Her website, and her conversation with me, are her keeping that promise. She is now working with Janet's estate to bring Janet's books back into print, so a new generation can learn from her.

Points to sit with

Whether you run a company, lead a team or are simply trying to make a big decision, here is what Nancy's story, the research and my own mistakes have taught me about trusting your gut without being reckless.

  1. Do the homework, then get quiet. Nancy read three newspapers a day and knew what every central bank was doing. Intuition is not a replacement for knowing your field. It is what happens when that knowledge settles and you stop forcing it.

  2. Notice where your gut has earned trust. Kahneman and Klein's research shows instinct is most reliable where you have real experience and honest feedback. My gut about people and deals was sharp because I had been reading them for years. Ask yourself whether this feeling comes from experience, or from wanting something to be true.

  3. Keep your positions to yourself for a while. Once you announce a decision, you have to defend it. Give yourself room to change your mind before you go public.

  4. Trust the signal, question the translation. A strong feeling usually means something. If the outcome isn't what you expected, look again at how you read it before you write the feeling off.

  5. Watch for the moment you move into your head. For me, stress and success arrived together. When you notice yourself overthinking, checking and controlling, that is often the point you have stopped listening.

  6. Make stillness part of the job. Prayer, meditation, a walk, five quiet minutes before a meeting. Nancy calls it cutting off the outer world. Whatever you call it, intuition needs space to be heard.

  7. Experiment with it. Write down your gut call before a decision, then look back at how it played out. Over time you will learn what your intuition feels like when it is right.

The quiet voice is a superpower

The people who walked out of Nancy's office at Lehman Brothers thought they had heard something ridiculous. Decades later, some of the most serious research in psychology agrees with her more than they would have believed. Janet spent her life proving that the connection between this world and the next is real. Nancy spent hers quietly using a gift that most people around her never knew she had.

I have used that same gift in a police car, across a negotiating table and now in my mediumship. The lesson has been the same every time. When I trust it and stay grounded, things flow. When I override it and try to control everything, they don't.

That is why I truly believe the quiet voice is a superpower. When you listen to how you feel, it can make your life flow in ways you could never have imagined, with an abundance you might never have believed possible. And it all starts with trusting what you feel.

You can hear Nancy tell her story in her own words in the full Soul Sync episode above. You can find out more about her work at nancynohavec.com. If you would like to understand your own intuition more deeply, my free online development circle meets on Tuesdays, and everyone is welcome (join the circle).

Frequently asked questions

Is intuition real, or just guessing? Research suggests intuition is real and often reliable, particularly where people have long experience and honest feedback. Studies have shown the body reacting to risk before the conscious mind catches up. It is not infallible, so it works best alongside facts, not instead of them.

Can intuition really help in business? Yes. Surveys of senior managers show intuition is widely used in strategic decisions, especially under time pressure and uncertainty. Experienced executives often turn years of analysis into instinctive judgements.

Who was Rev. Janet Nohavec? Janet Nohavec was an American evidential medium, a former Sister of Charity and the founder of The Journey Within Spiritualists' National Union church in Pompton Lakes, New Jersey. She was an approved overseas tutor at the Arthur Findlay College, wrote Through the Darkness and Where Two Worlds Meet, and passed to spirit in July 2022.

Who is Nancy Nohavec? Nancy Nohavec is an evidential medium and Janet's younger sister. She was Chief Trader of precious metals at Shearson Lehman Brothers in the 1980s and later worked in the fine art and antiques world.

Sources

Jason Paul, psychic medium

Would you like a reading with me?

Warm, honest readings on Zoom, from wherever you are in the world. £50 for 30 minutes, with an optional free recording of your reading for you to keep.

See readings and book

Developing your own mediumship? Join my online classes or the free online circle.

Jason Paul Medium

Jason Paul is an evidential medium based in Bristol, giving private readings online to clients across the UK and around the world. He is the grandson of medium and healer Eddie Paul, and came to mediumship after careers as a police officer and the founder of a legal recruitment business. Jason hosts the Soul Sync podcast and teaches online psychic and mediumship development classes.

https://www.jasonpaulmedium.com
Next
Next

The Natural Medium: Why Trying Gets in the Way of Your Mediumship